Analysis: An unprecedented debate could shake up a White House race like no other

CNN —

The confrontation in Atlanta between Joe Biden and Donald Trump Thursday night has a good chance of becoming the most fateful presidential debate in US history.

For the first time, a sitting president and an ex-president will lock horns before millions of viewers, in an encounter taking place far earlier than normal — even before the party conventions. The CNN-hosted showdown is the most pivotal moment yet in a neck-and-neck election, and it’s Biden’s best chance to shake up a reelection bid that he is in deep danger of losing as he struggles to convince voters that he’s delivered the political and economic normality he promised in 2020.

The debate comes at a moment when many Americans are seeking relief from high prices that have made it harder to feed their families and afford rents, mortgages, and new cars. It is unfolding amid an intense national debate over access to abortion that was unleashed by the conservative Supreme Court majority built by Trump. Deep divides over immigration and foreign policy in a world filled with new challenges to US power will form a contentious backdrop to a clash between two candidates who openly disdain one another. The debate in that sense personifies an election race that has left millions of Americans unsatisfied with the choice offered by two elderly candidates who alienate more voters than they attract.

But the momentous circ*mstances of the occasion can only be fully understood alongside the context of the unprecedented politics of the times. Since Sen. John F. Kennedy and Vice President Richard Nixon stagedthe first televised debatein the 1960 campaign, there have been agonizingly close elections that have set the country on a sharply different course. But the stakes in 2024 are greater than ever because of Trump’s attempt to disrupt the peaceful transfer of power based on false claims of fraud in the 2020 election and his promise to wage a never-before-seen presidency of personal vengeance if he wins in November.

Live Updates

President Joe Biden and former President Donald Trump are seen during a CNN Presidential debate in Atlanta on June 27, 2024. Austin Steele/CNN

Biden and Trump trade barbs at CNN presidential debate

Fact check: Trump on migrants and crime

CNN Flash Poll: Majority of debate watchers say Trump won debate over Biden

Fact check: Trump onPelosi and January 6

Fact Check: Trump falsely claims the Supreme Court “approved” the abortion pill

Fact check: Trump on his own comments on January 6

Fact Check: Trump again claims his tax cuts were the largest in history

Fact Check: Trump falsely claims there was “no terror” during his administration

Scalise says Trump won the debate and Biden is “not fit” for another term

Sen. Marco Rubio says he thinks more Americans feel they were better off when Trump was president

Fact check: Trump on the US trade deficit with China

Keeping Kamala Harris under wraps for 3 years was "political malpractice," CNN's John King says

Newsom: "I will never turn my back on President Biden"

Voters should focus on Biden's accomplishments, not his debate performance, vice president says

Harris admits Biden had "a slow start," but says he had "a strong finish" in debate

Here are some takeaways from tonight's CNN’s presidential debate between Biden and Trump

Fact check: Trump on the impact of immigration on Medicare and Social Security

Fact check: Trump on his own comments after 2017 Charlottesville march

Fact check: Trump on Democrats killing babies “after birth”

Biden campaign chair says the president provided a "positive and winning vision"

Fact check: Trump repeats lie about 2020 election

Analysis: Biden's inability to "shut down" Trump's lies was at heart of the problem, CNN's Abby Phillip says

Nancy Pelosi's office fires back against Trump's debate comments about January 6

Julián Castro says Biden "failed to clear" an already low bar set for his performance

In pictures: Biden and Trump face off in CNN presidential debate

Fact check: Trump on other countries doing business with Iran during his presidency

Biden's Friday: Campaigning in North Carolina before heading to New York

"The candidacy has fallen," analyst says on Biden's performance

Fact check: Biden on border crossings dropping during his administration

Trump advisers were celebrating Trump's performance

Fact check: Trump's false claim on tariffs

Fact check: Trump repeats frequent false claims about hiscriminal cases

Catch up on the key lines from the first presidential debate

Biden on Trump post-debate: "We need to beat this guy"

Fact check: Trump on Biden and a Ukrainian prosecutor

Fact check: Trump's claims on job growth during Biden’s presidency

Fact check: Trump on the Paris climate accord

Fact check: Biden's false statement on Black unemployment

Former aide, who believes Trump is a threat to democracy, says she's not confident Biden can beat him

"That was painful," Van Jones reacts to Biden's debate performance

2 Democratic Party officials express concerns about Biden’s performance

RFK Jr. slams Biden and Trump for answers on national debt and Covid

Trump campaign declaring victory before the end of the debate

Trump finishes ahead of Biden in speaking time at the close of the debate

Fact check: Trump falsely claims Biden has used the term “super predators”

Here's the state of the US economy on debate night

The candidates are discussing Russia’s war in Ukraine. Here’s where things stand

Biden attacks Trump on immigration actions: "He was taking — separating — babies from their mothers"

The candidates are slamming each other's records on immigration. Here’s a look at their stances

Biden on Trump's Roe v. Wade claims: "Simply not true"

Biden calls the overturning of Roe v. Wade "a terrible thing"

Trump says he will not block abortion medication as president

Trump says Biden's jobs were all post-pandemic "bounceback" jobs. But that's not the full story

The candidates are being asked about abortion rights. Here’s how Biden and Trump’s stance on the topic varies

Trump and Biden trade blame over inflation

Trump calls withdrawal from Afghanistan the "most embarrassing day" in the country's history

The candidates are discussing the economy. Here are key things to know

Biden and Trump did not shake hands

The hosts are giving a rundown of the rules. Here's reminder

The CNN presidential debate has started

We’re tracking who’s speaking the most – and the least – at tonight’s debate

Biden jokes about Trump's suggestion he will use performance enhancers in pre-debate social-media post

Donald Trump's spin room is a who's who of potential vice presidential candidates

Biden campaign’s mission: Shatter the impression that so many Americans have from snippets on social media

Joe Biden has a history of putting in a lot of preparation, biographer says

Biden has best fundraising hour of his campaign ahead of the debate, official says

Here's what to watch for during tonight's CNN presidential debate

Newsom argues young voters dissatisfied with 2024 candidates should focus on ideas, not age

The debate is starting soon. These are the rules Biden and Trump have agreed to follow on stage

These are the rules for tonight's debate

Trump and his team are hyper-focused on performance and visuals

Biden campaign launching paid media blitz tonight around the debate

Biden has prepared for Trump to potentially insult his family

Here's how members of Congress are watching the debate tonight

Here's how Biden and Trump's campaign promises differ when it comes to education

"I know Joe is ready to go," Jill Biden tells supporters hours before tonight's debate

Trump will be direct and speak to voters on the debate stage, potential vice president pick says

Trump is not accompanied by his wife as he arrives in Atlanta for debate

Biden and Trump both embrace tariffs. Here's what you should know about their policies

Trump’s estranged niece says she will support Biden: “I’m in Atlanta tonight to remind everyone who Donald is”

Trump has landed in Atlanta for debate

Ahead of CNN debate, some Black Georgians say they will vote for Biden reluctantly

Arizona Republicans say they want Trump to be on his "best behavior"

Arizona's Biden supporters express confidence that he will perform well

Young Georgia residents express concerns about whether Biden and Trump can have a civil debate

These are Trump and Biden's stances on foreign policy

Biden campaign plans to air abortion-focused ad during presidential debate

Trump is en route to Atlanta with top advisers after days of debate prep

Biden team describes calm before the storm as the president greets supporters in Atlanta

These are Biden and Trump's campaign promises related to gun control and the Second Amendment

White House Correspondents' Association urgesCNN to allow pool reporteraccess to debate studio

Polls show a tight race between Trump and Biden heading into CNN debate

Jill Biden: Debate will make clear "two visions for America"

Abortion takes spotlight in 2024 election as Supreme Court dismisses appeal on Idaho ban

Biden will contrast his vision for America with that of "extreme Republicans" during debate

Trump posts climate talking points from his former EPA administrator ahead of debate

Bernie Sanders says Biden needs to "make it clear" who is on working families' side on debate stage

Catch up on key facts about Biden and Trump ahead of tonight's debate

Biden posts social media video calling Trump "unfit" for office

Top House Democrat says he expects Biden to tout record and look ahead to second term during debate

Get ready for CNN's historic debate tonight with this list of resources

Biden campaign launches new website landing page attacking Trump's agenda

Harris will participate in debate livestream hosted by campaign Thursday

Georgia Republican voter says he will be paying attention to every nuance during tonight's debate

RNC chair says Trump will have “conversation about two Americas” at CNN debate

Biden blames GOP agenda while acknowledging Supreme Court decision "ensures" Idaho women can receive care

Supreme Court dismissal of Idaho abortion ban appeal comes hours ahead of tonight's debate

Diplomats will focus on what Trump says and how Biden presents himself in tonight's debate

Trump campaign takes direct aim at Harris in new ad

Behind the scenes of CNN's presidential debate: Here's how it will work

Trump claims Biden is a threat to the country in Truth Social post hours ahead of debate

Biden is not planning to reveal any new policies or personnel at debate, sources say

Tonight's the first debate of the cycle. It has a history of tripping up incumbents

Trump team closely monitoring reports on Biden’s debate prep and reviewing "game tape"

Biden plans to frame January 6 insurrection as "seismic" era-defining moment for voters during debate

Fueled by lasagna and tacos, here's how Biden and his aides prepared at Camp David

The Supreme Court has yet to rule on Trump's immunity claim. More opinions are expected today

Biden team is positioning a robust debate rapid response effort

Biden campaign reiterates that "it’s fair" for Americans to consider age when watching debate

The qualification requirements for CNN's first 2024 presidential debate

Biden campaign launches 7-figure "media blitz" ahead of CNN debate

Biden aides say handshakes unlikely tonight

Sen. Tim Scott advises Trump to remember Biden’s “provocative racial past” ahead of debate

Allies urgeTrumpto focus oninflation, immigration and crime at debate

Rep. Byron Donalds claims he's heard among the Black community that Trump convictions are "not right"

Biden team used debate prep to practice with time constraints

Biden campaign co-chair says Biden will show Americans the differences between him and Trump tonight

Here's 8 things to watch for in the debate between Biden and Trump

Biden team sees fluid schedule Thursday before Atlanta departure

Here's what the debate stage will look like

Analysis: Debate could shake up a White House race like no other

See all updates (180+)

Biden plans to frame what he sees as Trump’s threat to the rule of law and democracy in the starkest terms, sources familiar with the matter told CNN’s Kayla Tausche. He will describe the mob attack by Trump’s supporters on the US Capitol on January 6, 2021, as a “seismic,” era-defining moment that must be a watershed for voters.

“The embodiment of the threat is returning,” said one Biden source.

That backdrop means this presidential debate has a different cast than all its predecessors.

Had Sen. John Kerry beaten President George W. Bush in 2004 or ex-Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney made President Barack Obama a one-term president in 2012, there would have been significant political change. But the character of the republic and its global posture would not have fundamentally altered. That assurance cannot be applied with any confidence to the current election. Trump’s strongman impulse – epitomized by his claim before the Supreme Court that presidents have almost limitless power, as well as a blueprint for hardline new policies on immigration, the economy and foreign policy – means a second term could bring massive disruption.

“(It is) unbelievably historic. You cannot (over) hype up the importance of this,” presidential historian Douglas Brinkley told CNN’s Wolf Blitzer on Wednesday.

Democrats are desperate for the 81-year-old Biden to put on a show of vitality and sharpness amid concerns about his age. Seventy-eight-year-old Trump’s biggest liability might be himself and the possibility of a performance that could validate Biden’s warnings that he’s too “unhinged” to be president.

Biden is expected to hammer Trump over abortion — one of the few policy areas where he outpolls the former president — and his admiration of foreign dictators. Trump is already signaling he’ll portray Biden’s America in dystopian terms, beset by uncontrolled immigration, rampant crime and searing economic pain. The most extraordinary aspect of the debate is that it takes place less than a month after Trump was convicted in a criminal hush money case in New York. Biden has already highlighted the guilty verdict in campaign events, but Trump insists that he’s the victim of an attempt to weaponize the legal system to interfere in the election.

Both candidates are facing extreme pressure

Both men will hope to avoid the kind of debate night gaffes or odd personal quirks that have often gone viral and dominated critical post-debate media coverage that helps cement the perception of who won and who lost in voters’ minds. Vice President Al Gore’s theatrical sighs in 2000 and President George H.W. Bush’s unwise glance at his watch in 1992 both became emblems of losing campaigns. The risks are now much higher because of social media.

Presidential debates don’t always decide who wins in November. But the tension surrounding this year’s first debate in June, rather than in September or October as usual, is palpable.

“The closer the election, the greater the chance that a debate could influence it,” said Aaron Kall, director of debate at the University of Michigan, who has conducted an in-depth study of every presidential debate. “A lot of times these mistakes reaffirm a caricature of one of the particular candidates that existed before it happened.” For Biden, that means no senior moments, and Trump would be advised to avoid outbursts that confirm Biden’s characterization of a tyrant in waiting.

Neither Trump nor Biden has debated since their final clash in the pandemic-disrupted 2020 campaign. And their preparation for one of the most important nights of their lives has reflected their character and political personas.

The president has been out of sight for days, huddled below the oaks, poplars and maple trees at the Camp David retreat with advisers, strategizing how to handle the most challenging debate foe in history. Fueled by lasagna and tacos, he’s taken part in mock debates, immersed himself in briefing binders and tried to anticipate Trump’s wild twists and diversions. It’s a debate camp in keeping with Biden’s view that he’s locked in an existential election duel with the soul of the nation on the line.

The former president hates mock debates and has instead honed his preparation at rallies and events, trusting his instincts and intuition and a feral sense of an opponent’s political weakness. He has, however, had policy refresher sessions with aides and some potential vice-presidential picks including Ohio Sen. J.D. Vance and Florida Sen. Marco Rubio.

Biden has raised the stakes for himself heading into the debate higher than those any modern president faced. He argues Trump is a criminal in whom something has “snapped” and who is too dangerous and reckless to be let back into the White House. He’s also rebuked Trump for using Nazi-style language and warned democracy and freedom are on the ballot along with the capacity of ‘We the People’ to shape America’s destiny.

Preparing for anything at Camp David

Biden’s debate team is led by former White House chief of staff Ron Klain, who has been prepping Democrats for presidential debates for a generation. One of Klain’s mantras is “while you can lose a debate any time, you can only win it in the first 30 minutes.” Biden is therefore expected to front-load the most important points to appeal to the likely highest rated part of the primetime event.

The Biden team has been poring over Trump’s recent public interviews and speeches while workshopping responses to whatever he and the moderators may throw Biden’s way. The president will be ready for whichever version of Trump shows up – whether it’s the bombastic opponent who talked over and insulted him in their first clash in 2020, or a more restrained challenger seeking to project stability. If Trump aims for a presidential bearing, Biden has a locker full of practiced attacks and rebuttals designed to provoke him into making the outbursts that could turn voters off.

A Biden adviser told CNN that debate preparations have included getting the president ready to respond should Trump get personal — weeks after his son Hunter was convicted of felony gun charges. Biden’s love and protective instinct for his family is always close to the surface, and he reacted furiously when the then-president brought up Hunter during their first debate in 2020.

Biden has been running through his paces inside a large hangar at the Maryland retreat, where there’s a mock debate stage complete with bright television lights. His personal attorney, Bob Bauer, is playing Trump and other aides have sat in as CNN moderators Dana Bash and Jake Tapper.

But sources told CNN that the debate practice was about more than feeling comfortable. It’s also about answering the age question. Aides and allies of the president alike have frequently pointed to his State of the Union address in March as a model example of Biden at his best. He was energetic, focused and nimble, they’ve argued, over the course of his 67-minute prime-time speech.

Trump’s debate prep is as unorthodox as he is

Sitting presidents often have a rude awakening at first presidential debates, since they are unused to anyone getting in their grill and contradicting them. But Trump’s advantage on this score may be compromised since he refused to debate any of his GOP primary rivals this year. Still, his aggressive debate style isn’t much different from the belligerent, spiky attitude he displays in most public events.

Trump has warmed up for the debate by suggesting that Biden will be “jacked up” on drugs, as his aides frantically have tried to dismantle the expectations trap that the ex-president constructed for himself by suggesting that Biden is so mentally diminished that he can barely stand up or finish a sentence. In any other era, the idea of a candidate accusing an opponent of doping would be unthinkable. But Trump’s tactic is a reminder of a presidency and a political style that has shattered all previous norms.

In a new memo on Wednesday, Trump’s campaign signaled that the ex-president would assail Biden over immigration and the economy. It boasted about polling averages that his team says show the former president up in all the key states.

And Trump, whose administration created a gale of daily falsehoods, characteristically worked to accuse Biden of the very transgression that is most associated with him — lying. “The man is a walking lying machine and a fact-checker’s dream,” Trump wrote on Truth Social, while accusing Biden, one of the best presidential golfers, of being unable to hit a ball 10 yards.

Trump’s unorthodox approach means that the country may get another reminder of the chaos, discord and cacophony that it experienced in his four years in office — and that his supporters love and want to restore.

But it’s also a risk that could play into Biden’s desire to get voters to see the contrast between the 45th and 46th presidents that he believes could deliver him the election.

Former Obama speechwriter Terry Szuplat said successful debate performances tell a coherent story of where the country is and where it is going.

“It’s a story about yourself. Why you’re the right candidate. Why the other candidate is the wrong candidate.And it’s a story about the future. Every election is about the future. It’s a choice about the future,” Szuplat told CNN’s Kasie Hunt.

Neither Trump nor Biden has so far fulfilled that goal. Thursday is the best chance to do so.

Analysis: An unprecedented debate could shake up a White House race like no other | CNN Politics (2024)

Both candidates are facing extreme pressure

Preparing for anything at Camp David

Trump’s debate prep is as unorthodox as he is

References